Scoring Results from Pitches

These results were human verified and AI calculated.

31KB

Prof Practice Freelance Presentations.csv

Open

Top 5 Scores

The top 5 scoring presenters, based on the mean of the three scoring categories ("Content is relevant...", "Delivery is clearly heard...", and "Visuals are of a professional quality..."), are:

1. Elizabeth Hernandez: $4.86$

2. Sierra Crisp-Johnson: $4.64$

3. Tristan Holdren: $4.58$

4. Kenia Uribe: $4.56$

5. Alex Nettles: $4.50$

Objective Comments

The determination of "best comments" is subjective, so I analyzed the data using two metrics: the quantity of comments (indicating the level of engagement or feedback received) and the average length of comments (indicating more detailed or substantive feedback).

See link for results.

Presenters with the Highest Number of Comments (Quantity)

1. Kaitlyn Ott 12

2. Jaeden Ives-Crow 10

3. Sierra Crisp-Johnson 10

4. Kenia Uribe 9

5. Alex Nettles 8

Presenters with the Longest Average Comment Length (Detail)

Presenter Average Comment Length (Characters) 1. Bea Smith 161.71

1. Brittany Wallace 133.14

2. Kessi Newman 130.57

3. Kenia Uribe 129.11

4. Fabian Meza-Cera 108.43

Subjective Comments

I subjectively analyzed the comments by using a simple keyword-based sentiment analysis, counting positive and negative terms for each comment. A Positivity Ratio was then calculated for each presenter by dividing their number of 'Positive' comments by their total number of comments.

Based on this analysis, the presenter who received the most overwhelmingly positive feedback (among those with at least three comments) is Tristan Holdren.

See link to results.

Presenter Positivity Ratio Total Comments Breakdown (Positive / Neutral/Mixed / Negative)

1. Tristan Holdren 71.43% 7 5 / 0 / 2

2. Alex Nettles 62.50% 8 5 / 3 / 0

3. Ella Nielsen 60.00% 5 3 / 1 / 1

4. Kaileb Cardle 57.14% 7 4 / 3 / 0

5. Kenia Uribe 55.56% 9 5 / 3 / 1

Sample Comments for Tristan Holdren (Most Positive)

The feedback for Tristan Holdren frequently used positive terms, suggesting a general approval of the presentation style and quality.

• "Relaxed and coherent! Good job."

• "Great muli-media design."

• "Presenter is relaxed, well heard, and presentation looks nice as well. Design is done well."

• "I liked that the slides design and portfolio work had different styles, it shows that he can be flexible."